The 10 Best/Must-Read Individual Batman Comic Book Stories Of All-Time! (Part 2 of 2) Author: Robert Reineke
There have been thousands of Batman stories and picking ten that would satisfy everyone is an impossible task. So, consider this is a list of ten great stories that try to encompass the totality of Batman, hitting on many varied aspects. I further limited myself to issues that can more or less stand on their own. As great as the third part of “Year One” is, you can’t really appreciate it in a vacuum without reading the first two parts so I didn’t include that or a whole bunch of issues that are great as part of a longer arc but need that added context. Given that the one or two-parter has largely disappeared in favor of longer arcs, which demand a different list, this list skews older.
But that’s enough explaining the methodology, on to the list. - Robert Reineke
EDITOR'S NOTE:CLICK HERE for Part 1 of Robert's op-ed. - Jett
#5DETECTIVE COMICS #457 – “There’s No Hope in Crime Alley” by Dennis O’Neil and Dick Giordano
We’ve looked at the man who murdered Batman’s parents, now a story that focuses on Bruce Wayne and Gotham City. Batman returns to Crime Alley every year in memory of his parents, no matter what else is going on in Gotham. Batman himself states “Call it a reminder of who I am! Of my beginning and my probable end!”
All of that makes it an effective retelling of Batman’s origin. But the story also introduces Leslie Tompkins, a witness to the tragedy of that night who reached out to the newly orphaned Bruce Wayne and comforted him. Proving that even in Gotham City, in Crime Alley, there are good people willing to reach out and bring hope to the suffering.
Telling a Batman story featuring super villains, immense criminal conspiracies, and larger than life action comes with the territory. Telling a small intimate story featuring none of these things makes this a classic.
#4BATMAN #251 - “The Joker's Five Way Revenge” by Dennis O’Neil and Neal Adams
No great Batman stories list would be complete without the team of O’Neil and Adams. No great Batman stories list would be complete without The Joker. Here are both of them in one great package.
The Joker, under pressure from the publisher, the Comics Code Authority, and market forces, had steadily devolved from the ice cold killer of his first appearance to a mischievous prankster over the years, but as the 1970s rolled around it was time to return to the roots not only for Batman but for his greatest foe. We’re still following in Dennis O’Neil’s footsteps here with the Joker presented as a Batman obsessed, murderous psychopath with a flair for the ridiculous.
And, of course, Neal Adams knocks both the cover and the interior out of the park. Adams’ Batman was a lean martial artist and Adams completely sold the reality of the character while still drawing dyanamic, leap from the page artwork. It’s a complete winner of an issue.
#3DETECTIVE COMICS #439 - “Night of the Stalker” by Steve Englehart and Sal Amendola
A companion piece to “There’s No Hope In Crime Alley”, “Night of the Stalker” finds Batman hot on the trail of three criminals who have left a boy orphaned in the wake of a bank robbery. Where “There’s No Hope in Crime Alley” shows the human side of Batman, “Night of the Stalker” shows how the rage and grief turned Batman into a fearsome figure of justice as he relentlessly hunts the robbers down. The fact that Batman doesn’t utter a single word in his driven pursuit just makes him all the scarier.
That is until the case is over, the sun comes up, and Batman takes his cowl off and reveals the man that is still affected by the death of his parents. It’s a simple story, but it tells you everything you need to know about how frightening and inhuman Batman can be and how human he is under that image. Few stories even approach this one for showing the dichotomy of Batman.
#1 (tie)DETECTIVE COMICS #475-476 - “The Laughing Fish” & “The Sign of the Joker” by Steve Englehart & Marshall Rogers
This is perhaps stretching the definition of single issues to include, but I think you can pick both issues up and not be lost. It’s the culmination of a short but great run by Steve Englehart and Marshall Rogers. A run which touched on just about all of the aspects of Batman’s history to that point from the very beginning until the changes of the 1970s. It’s fitting that the run culminates in essentially a retelling of The Joker story from BATMAN #1. And it’s a great retelling. Dennis O’Neil brought back the homicidal to The Joker, but Steve Englehart brought the flat out insane and delusional to the self styled greatest criminal on earth.
It’s one thing to write a villain that just wants to rob a bank or is simply out for revenge. That’s understandable. It’s another to write a villain of such random chaos that he wants to patent fish. And will commit a series of fiendish, intricately planned murders to get his way. The combination of ego, randomness, and irrational goals have stuck, along with the out of the box cleverness, and effected every portrayal since.
That alone is enough to make the story a classic. But Englehart loads the two issues with enough drama to keep Batman’s mind focused elsewhere. Boss Thorne has worked his political wiles against Batman and gotten a warrant issued for Batman’s arrest, which just hampers Batman’s efforts as he perseveres in doing what’s right, not what’s strictly legal. Of course, Boss Thorne has his own problems, which helps makes him a character that exists as part of this world rather than a side issue, with The Joker (!) warning him off and the “ghost” of Hugo Strange persecuting him. It’s a strange world where Batman’s enemies are also his allies.
To top it off, Bruce Wayne’s girlfriend Silver St. Cloud has recognized that Bruce Wayne and Batman are the same guy. And she’s not coping with it well. Something that Batman isn’t completely oblivious of. The fact that their relationship is treated as complicated and adult, makes the struggle with the fact that Silver St. Cloud recognizes there’s a good chance that every night out could be Batman’s last and not knowing if she can deal with that worry. There’s no villain that Batman can punch out to deal with that issue.
All of these threads come to a head in a brilliant, twisty story with gorgeous, inspired artwork. Batman triumphs, but there’s a price. That’s perhaps as good an end as Batman is ever likely to receive. If there’s one storyline that sums up the totality of Batman, this is it.
No list of this nature can hope to be definitive, but if I had to pick ten issues to try to illustrate just what Batman is and how good a story can be told with him, these would be the ten. And these ten could change tomorrow as there were so many candidates. So, don’t treat these as written in stone but as a starting point for discussion and think about, and write about, what makes a great Batman story and what are the great examples from his long history. - Robert Reineke
Robert Reineke is a Civil and Environmental Engineer residing in Wisconsin.
He earned a BS and MS degrees from the University of Wisconsin and has been reading Batman comics since the 1970s.
He’s of the firm belief that there are plenty of Batman comics written before Frank Miller that are worthy of discussion.
Robert is also writing a monthly column on the films of Akira Kurosawa at Where the Long Tail Ends.